Follow Us:

Is It Worth Repairing the Stove?

Comparing Stove Repair with Replacement

Stoves are the unsung heroes of our kitchens, serving up piping-hot meals day in and day out. However, when they start acting up, we’re faced with a dilemma: stove repair vs. replacement. In this blog, we’ll explore the factors affecting stove repair costs and delve into the benefits of stove repair. We’ll also uncover the telltale signs that it might be time to bid farewell to your old faithful stove and welcome a new one into your culinary world.

5 Factors Determining Stove Repair Expenses

When contemplating stove repair vs. replacement, several factors influence the cost of stove repairs:

1. Type of Stove

The type of stove significantly affects repair costs due to varying complexities and features. Common stove types and their impact on repair expenses:

  • Gas Stoves: Gas stoves are generally more straightforward regarding components and repairs. They are often less expensive to repair compared to electric stoves or high-end induction cooktops.
  • Electric Stoves: Electric stoves can have a wide range of heating elements and control systems, making repairs more complex and potentially more expensive.
  • High-End Stoves: Stoves with advanced features like convection ovens, touch-screen controls, or smart technology tend to have higher repair costs due to the complexity of their components.

2. Nature of the Issue

The specific nature of the stove problem you’re experiencing can greatly influence the repair cost. Common stove issues include:

  • Heating Element Malfunctions: Problems with heating elements, whether in gas burners or electric coils, can often be resolved with relatively inexpensive part replacements.
  • Control Panel and Electronics: Issues with the control panel, thermostat, or electronic components can be more expensive to repair, as they may require specialized parts and expertise.
  • Gas Leaks or Burner Problems: Repairing gas-related issues, such as leaks or burner problems, may involve higher costs due to safety concerns and the need for certified technicians.

3. Labor Charges

Labor charges for stove repairs can vary based on several factors:

  • Region: Labor rates differ by location, with urban areas generally having higher rates than rural ones. Living in your region can significantly affect the overall repair cost.
  • Technician Proficiency: More experienced and certified technicians may charge higher hourly rates, but they often complete repairs more efficiently and effectively, potentially saving you money in the long run.
  • Hourly Charges vs. Set Fees: Some repair companies charge hourly rates, while others offer fixed fees for specific services. Understanding the pricing structure of the technician or service provider can help you estimate labor costs more accurately.

4. Components and Materials

The choice between genuine manufacturer parts and third-party alternatives can impact the cost of stove repairs:

  • Genuine Parts: Using manufacturer-approved, genuine replacement parts tends to be more expensive but ensures compatibility and quality. These parts may be necessary for high-end stoves.
  • Third-Party Parts: Opting for third-party or aftermarket parts can reduce repair costs but may compromise the stove’s performance and longevity. The quality of third-party parts can vary, so research is essential.

5. Warranty and Service Agreements

Warranties and service agreements can have a significant influence on stove repair costs:

  • Role of Warranties: If your stove is still under warranty, the cost of certain repairs may be covered by the manufacturer. However, warranties typically have limitations and may not cover all issues.
  • Advantage of Extended Warranties: Some appliance owners opt for extended warranties or service contracts. While these agreements involve additional upfront costs, they can provide peace of mind by covering a broader range of repairs over an extended period.

Advantages of Fixing a Stove

When deciding between stove repair vs. replacement, there are several compelling advantages to repairing your stove:

Cost Efficiency

Repairing your stove is often a cost-efficient choice, especially considering the cost of stove repairs. It typically proves to be more budget-friendly than purchasing a new appliance. By opting for repairs, you can manage your expenses more prudently, particularly when dealing with other household financial obligations.

Environmental Considerations

Opting for stove repairs is an environmentally responsible decision. Repairing your stove helps reduce electronic waste and minimizes the consumption of new resources involved in manufacturing new appliances. This eco-conscious choice contributes to a more sustainable future by lessening your carbon footprint.

Retaining Familiarity

Repairing your stove maintains the familiarity you’ve built with its features and cooking nuances. Replacing it means adjusting to a new cooking experience, which can be challenging. Fixing your existing stove lets you cook confidently and efficiently with your favorite recipes and techniques.

Swift Resolution

Stove repair provides a faster solution than buying and installing a new stove, which involves research and setup. Repairs typically take hours to days, minimizing cooking disruptions and allowing you to resume meal preparation swiftly.

When Should You Opt for Replacement Over Repair?

When considering the dilemma of stove repair vs. replacement, key factors must be assessed before deciding to replace your stove.

Stove's Age

The age of your stove is a pivotal factor. Stoves typically have a lifespan of 10 to 15 years. As they age, the value of repairs diminishes. Frequent breakdowns and the unavailability of replacement parts for older units can repair impractical and costly problems.

Repair Frequency

Frequent breakdowns and recurring issues are signs that your stove might be nearing its end. If you find yourself constantly in need of repairs, it may be more cost-effective and convenient to invest in a new, reliable appliance.

Energy Efficiency Considerations

Modern stoves are designed for energy efficiency, offering potential long-term savings on utility bills. Newer models often feature advanced technologies that reduce energy consumption, making them an attractive option when balancing the cost of stove repairs and long-term utility expenses.

Financial Analysis

It’s essential to conduct a thorough financial assessment. When repair expenses rival or surpass the stove’s current market value or the price of a new model, it may be more sensible to opt for replacement. Consider the long-term cost implications, including repairs, maintenance, and energy consumption, when making this decision.

How Much Does It Cost To Fix A Stove VS Replace It?

Stove repair is the least costly of all home appliance repairs. The average cost for repairing your stove, according to Home Advisor, ranges between $50 and $200. The actual cost of repair will be determined by the severity of the damage your appliance is facing and the parts needed to have it fixed. Your location can also be a factor in the cost of repair of your appliance. A homeowner living in a city will not pay the same as one living in a rural area.

If you are going for a stove replacement, the price will be a little higher. Getting professional help for an electric or gas stove repair will cost you between $1000 and $3000. This price includes the cost of the appliance and the installation service if needed. As with many other appliances, a new stove’s cost depends on its brand and its features.  

From the above estimation, you understand why repairing your broken stove should be your first recourse. Go for a replacement only when your appliance has reached an advanced age or a repair will not help solve the appliance’s issues. So, to the question, “is it worth repairing a 15-year-old stove?” the answer is “yes!”.

Guidelines for Choosing Between Repair and Replacement

When faced with the decision of stove repair vs. replacement, following these guidelines can help you make an informed choice that aligns with your needs and budget.

  • Seek Multiple Estimates

    When evaluating the signs to replace a stove or considering repairs, gathering multiple repair quotes is crucial. This ensures you have a comprehensive view of the range repair costs and can select the most cost-effective option. Contrasting estimates allow you to identify competitive pricing and assess the trustworthiness of service providers.

  • Anticipate Upcoming Costs

    Look beyond the immediate repair needs and assess the overall condition of your stove. If you foresee imminent repairs or additional challenges, investing in a new stove may be wiser. Continuously repairing an aging appliance can accumulate costs and prove less cost-effective in the long run.

  • Assess Your Personal Requirements

    Ask yourself questions such as, “Does your stove align with your culinary needs?” and “Are there features in newer models you’re eyeing?” Consider whether your current stove meets your cooking preferences and whether upgrading to a more advanced model would enhance your culinary experience. This assessment helps ensure your decision aligns with your personal requirements and cooking habits.


In conclusion, when considering stove repair vs. replacement, factors like repair costs, environmental impact, and personal preferences come into play. Seek estimates, anticipate future expenses, and evaluate your culinary needs for an informed decision. Repairing your stove is often cost-efficient, eco-friendly, and maintains familiarity. However, replacement might be practical for aging, frequently malfunctioning, or inefficient stoves. Align your choice with your kitchen needs and budget.

For professionalappliance repairs, trust 5 Star Appliance Repair. We specialize in various brands, including Viking, Thermador, KitchenAid, Samsung, Kenmore, Maytag, Wolf, and more. Make the wise decision and contact us today for expert stove repair and range repair services. Discover the benefits of stove repair with 5 Star Appliance Repair.

FAQs on Cost of Stove Repairs

The cost of stove repairs for a gas stove can vary but tends to be lower than that for an electric stove due to simpler components and fewer potential issues.

Common stove repair issues include malfunctioning burners, faulty igniters, and temperature control problems. Stove repair costs vary but typically range from $100 to $500, depending on the issue’s complexity.

It becomes more economical to replace a stove when the repair cost exceeds 50% of its value or when frequent repairs indicate a declining appliance, often around 8-10 years old.

Modern stoves are typically more energy-efficient than older models, potentially reducing long-term operating costs and favoring repair over replacement.

Yes, warranties and service plans can offset stove repair costs. They’re worth considering for long-term savings and peace of mind.